Case law > Decision of the Regional Court in Warsaw 25th Civil Division of 28th April 2020

Decision of the Regional Court in Warsaw 25th Civil Division of 28th April 2020
XXV C 461/18

  1. In charges regarding the group membership the defendant should focus on proving that a specific person cannot obtain a group member status. Therefore the charges shall show, as was already said above, that the claim of a specific person (persons) does not have the characteristics of a specific group or does not present a factual link to the claims of other group members or that it is not of the same kind as the group claim. What is important, the defendant’s statements, according to generally applicable procedural rules, shall be proved in a proper manner by presenting relevant evidence.

The Regional Court in Warsaw 25th Civil Division in the following ruling bench:

Presiding Judge: Anna Pogorzelska, Regional Court Judge

having examined on 28th April 2020 in Warsaw at the hearing in camera the group action filed by the District Consumer Ombudsman in District (…) against (…) S.A. with its registered office in W. for payment on the composition of the group

decides to:

  1. on the basis of Article 17 of the Act on Pursuing Claims in Group Proceedings determine the composition of the group and its division into subgroups which shall include the following persons:
  • subgroup 1: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 1,785.35)
  • subgroup 2: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 2,3788.06)
  • subgroup 3: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 2,940.19)
  • subgroup 4: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 3,330.17)
  • subgroup 5: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 3,409.07)
  • subgroup 6: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 3,591.32)
  • subgroup 7: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 3,834.91)
  • subgroup 8: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 4,587.63)
  • subgroup 9: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 5,440.21)
  • subgroup 10: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 6,171.05)
  • subgroup 11: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 6,661.92)
  • subgroup 12: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 7,083.43)
  • subgroup 13: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 7,218.11)
  • subgroup 14: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 7,387.30)
  • subgroup 15: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 7,554.46)
  • subgroup 16: [data of 6 group members] (PLN 7,554.54)
  • subgroup 17: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 7,702.63)
  • subgroup 18: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 7,733.94)
  • subgroup 19: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 7,930.64)
  • subgroup 20: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 8,166.72)
  • subgroup 21: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 8,420.27)
  • subgroup 22: [data of 6 group members] (PLN 9,141.55)
  • subgroup 23: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 10,223.96)
  • subgroup 24: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 10,534.55)
  • subgroup 25: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 10,725.08)
  • subgroup 26: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 10,801.59)
  • subgroup 27: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 10,953.80)
  • subgroup 28: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 11,112.98)
  • subgroup 29: [data of 2 people] (PLN 11,501.08)
  • subgroup 30: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 11,501.12)
  • subgroup 31: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 11,646.00)
  • subgroup 32: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 12,112.63)
  • subgroup 33: [data of 5 group members] (PLN 12,369.30)
  • subgroup 34: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 13,579.64)
  • subgroup 35: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 13,883.94)
  • subgroup 36: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 13,903.29)
  • subgroup 37: [data of 3 people] (PLN 14,063.05)
  • subgroup 38: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 14,497.37)
  • subgroup 39: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 14,830.64)
  • subgroup 40: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 14,908.01)
  • subgroup 41: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 15,455.76)
  • subgroup 42:  [data of 2 group members] (PLN 15,829.14)
  • subgroup 43: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 16,128.52)
  • subgroup 44: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 16,427.42)
  • subgroup 45: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 16,567.35)
  • subgroup 46: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 16,764.51)
  • subgroup 47: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 17,971.13)
  • subgroup 48: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 18,598.24)
  • subgroup 49: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 18,988.53)
  • subgroup 50: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 19,821.13)
  • subgroup 51: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 20,806.51)
  • subgroup 52: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 21,109.69)
  • subgroup 53: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 21,760.75)
  • subgroup 54: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 22,146.13)
  • subgroup 55: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 23,139.44)
  • subgroup 56: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 23,511.12)
  • subgroup 57: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 25,155.11)
  • subgroup 58: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 28,343.42)
  • subgroup 59: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 32,726.27)
  • subgroup 60: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 34,796.52)
  • subgroup 61: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 36,337.83)
  • subgroup 62: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 44,540.22)
  • subgroup 63: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 54,094.36)
  • subgroup 64: [data of 4 group members] (PLN 63,054.54)
  • subgroup 65: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 66,360.70)
  • subgroup 66: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 87,692.94)
  • subgroup 67: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 8,894.45)
  • subgroup 68: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 9,334.29)
  • subgroup 69: [data of 1 group member] (PLN 17,004.60)
  • subgroup 70: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 17,172.07)
  • subgroup 71: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 17,688.12)
  • subgroup 72: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 17,964.84)
  • subgroup 73: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 28,494.19)
  • subgroup 74: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 33,587.43)
  • subgroup 75: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 55,363.92)
  • subgroup 76: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 155,940.72)
  • subgroup 77: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 4,103.83)
  • subgroup 78: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 14,397.49)
  • subgroup 79: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 5,659.78)
  • subgroup 80: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 8,605.62)
  • subgroup 81: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 9,519.14)
  • subgroup 82: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 10,061.31)
  • subgroup 83: [data of 1 group member] (PLN 18,048.05)
  • subgroup 84: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 31,194.08)
  • subgroup 85: [data of 2 group members] (PLN 35,929.29)
  • subgroup 86: [data of 3 group members] (PLN 58,691.95)
  • subgroup 87: [data of 1 group member] (PLN 39,770.92)

2. refuse to grant the status of a group member to the following persons: [data of 27 people].